Love Hurts: 440lb Virgin Sends Lover To ER During His First Time

Discovery Fit & Health


The first time Gregg Casarona ever had sex, the walls didn’t just shake — they crumbled. The 440-pound man was 21 at the time and had been dating his girlfriend Jen Gerakaris for about a month when they decided to take things to the next level. Welcome to the new TLC series “Sex Sent Me to the ER,” premiering Dec. 28.



Gerakaris was 22 and living in her parents’ Long Island basement at the time. She made her move by stripping down to her bra and panties and waiting on her bed until Gregg got the hint.

“I knew he was a virgin and I honestly didn’t care,” Gerakaris says. “We were dating for a little while and he hadn’t put any moves on me yet so I made a move.”

When things began to heat up, Casarona thrust the 110-pound Gerakaris backwards with all 440 pounds of his girth. And Gerakaris’s head went right through the basement’s sheet-rock wall.

“My initial reaction was, ‘I killed her,’ ” Casarona tells The Post. “‘This is my first time. And Jen is dead.’”

After a couple of terrifying seconds, Gerakaris slowly pulled her head out of the wall and looked at Casarona incredulously.

“Why’d you stop?” she asked.

“He looked like he was about to have a heart attack,” she says. “So I just wanted to lighten the mood.”

But Gregg was shaken and insisted on taking his lover, who started to become dizzy and nauseous, to the hospital. She was diagnosed with a concussion.

Although Gerakaris and Casarona were shy about telling the doctors and nurses about what caused her injury, the pair will be sharing their tale on national TV next week.

Their story will be featured — with a PG-13-rated reenactment — in the premiere episode of “Sex Sent me to the ER.”

After bringing down the house, the couple says they were a little bit more careful about their positioning during sex.

“In the beginning, there were lots of pillows and we didn’t do it anywhere near a wall,” Gerakaris says.

The couple stayed together for 4 more years after that ER trip and remain close friends today. Casarona, now 28, has since dropped 220 pounds and Gerakaris, now 29, has a new boyfriend who knows about that wild night.

“I was friends with him before and, of course, our friends know the story,” Gerakaris says. “It’s a story we always tell over drinks.”

“But our families? No, they don’t know,” Gerakaris says with a laugh.

“My parents didn’t even know about the wall. I had Gregg fix it and thank God I still had matching paint.”


via NY Post